Kate Middleton Accused of Copying Meghan Markle’s Style With Belted Fall Outfit

For some time now, Kate Middleton and Meghan Markle have been accused of copying each other. Who is copying whom usually depends on who you ask: royal watchers who admire Kate often feel Meghan is copying her. Meanwhile, critics of the royal family have said the opposite.

And now that Prince Harry and Meghan are back in the United Kingdom, these claims have escalated once again. Most recently, one of Kate’s outfits sparked a discussion about whether she’s been taking fashion inspiration from Meghan. Some people insist that it’s obvious at this point, while others argue that this particular example seems like a bit of a stretch.

The outfits in question feature belts.

Mark Cuthbert/Getty Images

To some royal watchers, the similarities basically end there. To be fair, in comparison photos shared via Reddit, Kate and Meghan are both wearing dark-colored turtlenecks. The photo of Kate is from October 20. She appears to be wearing a dark green dress with a belt. Meghan’s “version” from October 15 is a dark brown turtleneck sweater paired with a purple skirt. Both ensembles do feature belts, but even the belts, arguably, look different.

So, is this another obvious example of the two women copying each other? Or is it simply two women dressing like it’s autumn in the United Kingdom? In this case, it also depends on whom you ask. The person who shared the photos to Reddit called Kate’s outfit a “sweet nod to Meghan” and wrote, “Meghan wore this ensemble five days before Kate. Was this a coincidence or was this deliberate?”

Some people said it happens too often to be a coincidence.

Jonathan Brady – WPA Pool/Getty Images

Their argument is that Kate and Meghan just so happened to be photographed wearing similar outfits one time, perhaps it would seem coincidental. However, they started sharing photos of other times in which Kate and Meghan sported very similar-looking outfits.

“She is absolutely taking style cues from Meghan,” one Redditor wrote. “Gone are the coat dresses and in now is monochrome and smart separates, there’s too many occasions of her doing this to say it isnt happening.”

Someone else said, “Yeah I’m scrolling down and all the examples you gave, once or twice could be a coincidence. But it’s too many. It’s a very clear pattern, not an accident.”

But others think Kate was actually dressing like… herself.

Jonathan Brady – WPA Pool/Getty Images

To some royal watchers, Kate’s outfit in that particular photo seems very much like something she would typically wear. And besides, a lot of commenters struggled to see the similarities between the two ensembles.

“I’m not seeing it,” one person wrote. “The green is so structured and the purple is flowy, the green looks like one piece, the purple is definitely two different fabrics. The belts aren’t similar. Am I missing something?”

Someone else said, “I don’t think she is really copying her. The color is totally different, as are the fabrics. The style is similar, that’s it.”

While the two women have been spotted in similar outfits before, some royal watchers thought this seemed more like an example of people pitting Kate and Meghan against each other for no reason. “Because both women wore a belt?” another person commented. “Be for real, this is ridiculous. Stop pitting two people against each other it’s exhausting.”

A fourth person described the two outfits as “two women wearing different women’s clothes in autumn.” They wrote, “I’m not seeing this as the same at all, even if copying has been a pattern. This is Kate dressing like Kate, in a dress with absurd shoulder pads. Fitted top, full skirt, belt to accentuate waist in a color she wears well and often.”

READ NEXT: Meghan Markle Accused Her Stylist of ‘Embarrassing’ Her in Flub Involving Kate Middleton