Kate Middleton Faces Criticism After Telling a Young Fan She Can’t Sign an Autograph

Since marrying into the royal family 15 years ago, Kate Middleton hasn’t strayed very far from royal protocol, and now, we know she doesn’t make exceptions in any situation — even for kids.

During an appearance in Mumbai, India earlier this week, Kate refused to sign an autograph for a child who asked her for one. But at the same time, a famous athlete who happened to be at the same event was more than happy to sign, and the stark contrast between these interactions is really sticking out to a lot of people.

Kate shut down the autograph request, but she did apologize.

Kate and husband Prince William have been visiting India this week while they’re in town for the Children’s Earthshot Awards, and that included a stop to visit with people from an organization called The Right Pitch, which introduces the game of cricket to children from underserved communities.

While meeting with the people who had gathered there, Kate was seen turning down a young fan’s request for her autograph, instead telling them, “Sorry, I can’t sign.”

Cricket star Sachin Tendulkar was happy to sign autographs.

In a stark contrast to Kate, cricket pro Sachin Tendulkar (who also happened to be at the event) was spotted doing the exact opposite of the Princess of Wales, happily signing autographs right next to her. The moment can be seen in a video that Hello! magazine shared on Instagram, and it looks a bit brutal watching from the outside.

People aren’t very impressed with Kate not signing an autograph for a kid, either, with one writing that she must not have been willing to “touch your commoner pen.”

Another wrote, “If Meghan did this, the comments would be vicious.” (To be honest, this is probably true.)

It’s against royal protocol for Kate (or anyone else in the monarchy) to sign autographs.

In reality, Kate actually couldn’t sign an autograph even if she wanted to, in accordance with official royal protocol — and neither can any of the other royals, for that matter.

It all goes back to security reasons. Basically, royals can’t sign documents because that could lead to their signature being forged or copied for other documents or for unauthorized merchandise.

This isn’t the only time that Kate has had to turn down an autograph in public, and it likely won’t be the last. And to her credit, she always seems apologetic when she does have to turn down an autograph.

Things are changing in the royal family, though. After all, the royals are now saying yes to selfies more than they once did, so who knows? Maybe we could see a change that allows them to sign autographs in the future, but for now, it’s still a no go.

READ NEXT: Kate Middleton’s Reaction During Cricket Game Has Royal Watchers Accusing Her of ‘Overacting’