Andy Cohen Mocked Julia Stiles’ Dancing & She Just Got the Perfect Chance To Make Him Regret It

Long before Julia Stiles joined Dancing with the Stars season 35, she had a little experience dancing on camera in the 2001 movie Save the Last Dance (if you’re a millennial, you know the movie).

After seeing her moves in that film, Andy Cohen bashed her dancing. But now that she’s competing on an actual dancing reality show, she’s proving him wrong — and she wants him to regret he ever said anything.

Last year, Andy made an offhand comment about Julia’s dance skills.

As AOL reported, Andy made the comment while he was talking to Julia’s Save the Last Dance costar Kerry Washington on his Radio Andy show in 2025.

“Can we all just agree that Julia Stiles is not the greatest dancer on the planet?” he said at the time.

Andy’s certainly entitled to his opinion, but here’s the thing: The scene he was talking about was when Julia’s character is auditioning for Julliard, and that wasn’t even her dancing. It was a body double.

And understandably, Julia is heated about the remark.

She absolutely killed it on the dance floor on DWTS this week.

Julia and her partner, Ezra Sosa, danced the quickstep to Dolly Parton’s 9 to 5, and they received a score of 18 out of 30 from the judges.

In the rehearsal footage that aired on the show, Julia made it clear that she knew exactly what Andy said about her and that she wasn’t going to let him forget it. In fact, she said that she stopped taking dance classes because people expected her to be this perfect dancer,” mentioning Andy by name, to which Ezra replied, “That diva?”

She admitted that what Andy said was “imprinted in my brain,” and vowed to win the Mirrorball trophy so she can confront him about her dance skills on the couch at Watch What Happens Live.

So of course, after Julia’s performance this week, judge Derek Hough brought it all full circle with his comment.

“Andy Cohen, you can eat it!” Derek said. “That was beautiful, graceful, you are absolutely beaming.”

Andy is willing to admit that he’s wrong.

Andy is eating his words, and to his credit, he’s not afraid to admit that he was wrong about Julia.

On the episode of Watch What Happens Live that aired that night, Andy admitted he was wrong, saying, “I am so sorry. I am the last person who should be giving anyone feedback on their dancing.”

He added, “Great job, Julia Stiles. You killed it tonight. You did amazing tonight, and I know you’re gonna have a great run. This diva gives all of you permission to flood my inbox with the 10 things you hate about me.”

See what he did there with that reference to another one of her most iconic movies? He just better not forget to invite her on the show after she wins that Mirrorball.

READ NEXT: Andy Cohen Records Son’s Cringey Car ‘Concert’ on Long Family Drive: ‘My Life’