‘The Swan’ Contestants Reveal the Lasting Damage Behind Reality TV’s Most Extreme Makeover Show

In the early 2000s, Fox hit it big with American Idol and wanted to capitalize on the excitement. Nely Galán had an idea for a show that would change women’s lives forever. The Swan would give them the chance to work with a life coach, a therapist, a personal trainer, and doctors to create the very best version of themselves. This was more than a simple makeover; this was taking an average woman and transforming her into a beauty pageant contestant right in front of our eyes.

The highly controversial show ran for two seasons in 2004. In just 18 episodes, the show gave us the very worst of reality television and ruined women’s lives. More than 20 years later, The Swan: Behind the Mirror on Hulu takes us behind the scenes with contestants, producers, and even one of the doctors to show what really happened.

‘The Swan‘ contestants got more than they bargained for.

In the early 2000s, reality TV shows found contestants the old-fashioned way, through radio and TV ads. More than 500,000 applied to be on The Swan because they wanted to transform their lives. What they didn’t know was that they’d be competing against each other in a beauty pageant.

But at the time, they wanted to change everything about themselves, so they committed to what producers wanted. Some women became ill; season 2’s Kari Bravata had a surgical complication that nearly killed her, and it was all documented for entertainment purposes.

One of the surgeons claims the documentary was inaccurate.

Dr. Randal Haworth, who performed many of the plastic surgery procedures alongside Dr. Terry Dubrow, participated in the documentary. Some of his comments, like one that made the surgeries sound pretty crude.

“When I speak in analogies, and this is what I’ve learned from this documentary, unfortunately, is that I may be quoted accurately, but you can still mischaracterize what I said in the context of things,” he told People.

“They would want to know who would make good TV — not in terms of their backstory. I’m just looking at their face. And my goal was as a plumber. Can I perform an early hyper-aesthetic surgery on these people?” He said in the documentary.

Haworth said he meant he contributed to the overall transformation.

He explained to People that a producer asked him if he was calling the women toilets, and he clarified.

“I was hired as a plastic surgeon to produce beautiful results, safe results, in the same way that a plumber would be hired to work on a house, even though that plumber has no say in the design or the facade of the house,’” he said.

Haworth thinks the documentary’s editors “sliced and diced” his interview in a “hurtful” way.

The contestants were hurt the most.

Some of them had physical pain from The Swan, but the emotional scarring is the hardest to watch. More than two decades later, some of the women who appeared on the show still feel duped.

Their stories are difficult to watch in the documentary. It takes us back to a dark time for body image, and the terrifying lengths networks would go to for ratings.

READ NEXT: Mom Who Documented Tummy Tuck Journey on TikTok Declared Brain-Dead After Complications