What to Know
The story of Lindsay Clancy has gripped the country for nearly four years. On January 23, 2023, her husband, Patrick Clancy, reportedly left the family’s home in Duxbury, Massachusetts, to pick up dinner. When he came back, he claimed he found his wife seriously injured outside the home and their three children, Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and 8-month-old Callum, strangled by exercise bands.
All three children died, and Lindsay Clancy became paralyzed from the waist down after jumping from a second-story window. Lindsay Clancy pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity.
During her five-week trial, the 12-person jury listened to multiple testimonies and deliberated for nearly seven days. One lone juror held out, unable to accept that Lindsay Clancy was not guilty, which led to a mistrial. Now his brother is speaking out.
Many blame the man’s faith for his inability to find Lindsay Clancy not guilty.
The juror’s Catholic faith became a theme in many online discussions about the holdout in Lindsay Clancy’s case, a detail his unidentified brother denies. “I don’t think religion had anything to do with it,” the man’s brother told the New York Post. The juror’s brother insists that he would have acted the same way if he were on a jury.
“He looked at the case, and he made the call,” the juror’s brother said. “For me, that’s how I would do it. I would just listen to the case with all the evidence and go from there.”
Some believe that the juror did the right thing by disagreeing with the not guilty verdict. Others claim he simply refused to follow the reasonable-doubt instructions.
A fellow juror noticed something strange about the holdout juror.
Juror Paula Devlin told the Daily Mail the man became upset during deliberations.
“The main thing he focused on is sometimes we would all want to talk at once, and that was very upsetting to him,” she claimed. “He would get upset and say, ‘Listen to what she’s saying, listen to what he’s saying, be respectful’.”
She added that the man seemed to have trouble with conversation.
“We were trying to say to him that sometimes somebody says something and they get lost in their thought, or they can’t find the right word, and somebody else puts that word in there for them or finishes their thought; that’s how normal conversation works,” Devlin said. “But when that would happen, he would get upset and just take all this time lecturing us about not being respectful.”
Others question the man’s criminal past.
Per the Post, the unidentified juror was arrested in 2021 after allegedly battering his wife because of their infant’s crying. A court dismissed the charges, but in 2025 the nephew who reportedly contacted authorities about the domestic violence incident alleged his uncle beat him. The nephew reportedly had a restraining order against his uncle that expired during the Lindsay Clancy trial.
Per court documents obtained by NBC 10, the nephew recounted the attack to police. “You ruined my (expletive) life,” the juror reportedly said as he punched the man in the face. “You’ve had this coming your way for a long time.”
The man and his family continue to face harassment.
The juror’s brother reportedly told the Post that he is a devout Catholic Haitian who immigrated to the United States. True crime enthusiasts allegedly camp out at the family’s home, creating an unbearable situation.
“My family cannot leave the house,” the brother said. “They are leaving notes at my mother’s house. They won’t leave us alone, and we don’t know anything.”
The man’s family reportedly had no idea he was on the jury.
The juror’s brother said no one in their family had any idea he was on the jury for Lindsay Clancy’s trial. The man kept his vow not to speak of the case outside the courtroom.
Florida Governor Ron DeSantis offered the man asylum following the mistrial.
“A man objected to allowing a woman to kill her three young kids and get away with it. So NBC is trying to smear that juror whose identity should be protected. Another low for legacy media. If the juror is being harassed, Florida will provide asylum. I’m sure he’d be welcomed and appreciated,” he wrote on X.
READ NEXT: Influencer Apologizes After Turning Lindsay Clancy Trial Into a Sponsored Betting Post