Mom Counts Calories for Her 10-Year-Old & Strangers Are Horrified by What Happens at Dinner

Raising teens and preteens in today’s world is not for the weak. Women in their thirties and forties may have thought we had it tough with magazine quizzes telling us we were fat. Today’s youth have body image thrown in their face 24 hours a day from a device in their pocket. As moms, it’s our job to guide our kids to be body positive while also making healthy choices. That combination can be much more challenging than it sounds. Even with the best intentions, parents say things that can have a long-lasting negative impact on their child’s self-image.

A mom on Reddit knows this all too well. She suggested her daughter order something from a “Skinnylicious” menu to save calories, and she’s being dragged in the comments. But did she do the wrong thing?

​The family went out for a typical dinner.

​The original poster claimed in Reddit’s AITA forum that she and her husband took their three kids to dinner at a restaurant. Her 10-year-old daughter, Jane, is considered “obese” by her doctor, and OP keeps an eye on what she eats. Jane evidently wanted to order a pasta with more than 1,000 calories, so OP suggested the “Skinnylicious chicken pasta” instead. OP didn’t mean any harm, but a couple at a nearby table didn’t like what she had to say. They all got up to go to the bathroom at the same time, and a confrontation ensued.

​“After my daughters left the bathroom, the girlfriend started blowing up on me, saying I’m encouraging bad eating habits for my child, and saying I’m a terrible mother.) the other women in the bathroom started chipping in and chewing me out,” OP wrote.

​OP had an eating disorder in her youth.

Busy Restaurnat
Radiokukka/iStock

​OP explained she struggled with food and body image for years and does not want her daughters to feel the same pain. She’s now wondering if she did the wrong thing offering a lower-calorie option. Her husband said “no,” but the comments disagreed. Several people chimed in, telling OP she made a mistake.

​“As a healthcare professional, I recommend not putting her in triggering situations where you would have to correct a behavior in front of other family members. she might feel uncomfortable,” one person wrote. “Nta.”

​“Agree, but I’m an eating disorder dietitian and what this mom did is how eating disorders start,” a professional wrote.  “So I say YTA.”

​“NTA, but I wonder if you could’ve suggested something with a less patronizing name. ‘Skinnylicious’ is just awful, and I’d feel awful if someone suggested that I eat that instead of what I wanted almost exclusively because of the name,” another person added.

​Some gave OP suggestions about how to handle the situation more delicately.

​Even if OP never wanted to cause her daughter any anguish, some felt OP should have let this go.

​“I would avoid redirecting her at restaurants. Manage the calories by the week not per day.i feel like a ten year old is a little too young to be talking about calories,” someone wrote.​

Others think food shaming is a hard no. Period.

“YTA Don’t food shame your kids, esp not in public . Get some professional help. You’re starting to understand how your ED can impact your child,” a comment reads.  “Never comment about what she’s eating. Ever. Let her doctor talk with her.”

In the end, OP claims Jane enjoyed her food, and the conversation had no effect on the meal, but left her with a lot to ponder.

READ NEXT: I Survived Anorexia & Learned There Is So Much More to Life Than an Eating Disorder