What to Know
A senior at Oceanside High School on Long Island will no longer be allowed on campus after a fight over a vaccine exemption. The 17-year-old student, identified in court documents as Sarah Doe, reportedly wanted an exemption for the final dose of the hepatitis B and meningitis shots required by New York law to attend school.
The teen’s mother, listed as Jane Doe, allegedly pleaded with school officials to allow for an exemption based on a past anaphylactic reaction. But when a judge looked at a signed request from a doctor, he reportedly found the man’s name on New York state’s Vaccine Fraud Awareness list. Now the student must either get the shots or miss her senior year.
The case has been ongoing for years.
According to court documents obtained by the New York Post, Sarah Doe was previously exempt from vaccinations due to religious reasons. In 2019, the state eliminated the exception due to a measles outbreak.
After the legal change, Sarah Doe reportedly received 18 vaccine doses over a six-week period to stay in school. Per the filing, this caused Sarah “repeated serious medical crises.”
Sarah Doe received a court order to attend school for her 2025-2026 school year.
Jane Doe obtained a judge’s order allowing her daughter to attend school for her junior year without receiving the final dose of the hepatitis B vaccine due to what a doctor called an “anaphylactic reaction.” For her senior year, she needed both the hepatitis B vaccine and the meningitis vaccine.
Dr. Carlos Rivera reportedly signed off on the exemption request, but told the court he not only failed to examine the teenager, but he’d also never even spoken to her prior to filing the request. In addition, his name appears on the state’s Vaccine Fraud Awareness list.
Oceanside High School requested more information on multiple occasions.

The court filing noted that Oceanside High School’s doctor, Antwan Haskoor, repeatedly asked for more information about the family’s request and “a specific reason why Sarah Doe can’t receive the meningitis vaccine.” Rivera reportedly “repeatedly and falsely” claimed he never had a request from Haskoor about the exemption.
Jane Doe allegedly lied under oath in court and told the judge she did not provide any additional health information to the school after telling officials she had. Haskor denied her vaccination request.
The judge sided with the school.
Eastern District Judge Gary Brown noted, “School officials were well within their rights to request further supporting documentation.” Instead of providing the information, Jane Doe reportedly had another doctor, named Miller, sign off on an exemption request similar to Rivera’s documentation. Sarah Doe’s attorney, Sujata Gibson, told The Defender her client did not receive fair treatment.
“When a school is on notice that a disabled child needs an accommodation, the ADA [Americans with Disabilities Act] places the burden on the school to show why it cannot provide it,” Gibson said.
“Here, the court effectively flipped that burden. The question became not how to accommodate Sarah and keep her safe, but whether the school district doctor had enough information to be required to accept the medical judgments of her treating physicians.”
It’s unclear whether Sarah Doe will remain out of school or receive the vaccinations to return to the classroom for her senior year.
READ NEXT: Midwife Allegedly Gave 1,500 Kids Pellets Instead of Vaccines & Lied on Official Records
You must be logged in to post a comment.