Mom Lets 5-Year-Old Walk Half a Mile Alone & Ends Up on the Child Abuse Registry for 7 Years

A Virginia mom, Karyann Parkinson, was convicted on a child abuse charge after she allowed her 5-year-old son to walk half a mile from their home in their gated community to a nearby pond. She was subsequently added to a child abuse and neglect registry in the state of Virginia, according to USA Today.

But what some parents are now arguing about on social media is whether her punishment was warranted. Karyann and her husband, Dallin Parkinson, seem to practice free-range parenting with their five kids, or a version of it.

Free-range parenting encourages independence in kids of various ages. And Karyann said at the time of her conviction that’s what she had given her 5-year-old, Samuel Parkinson.

The mom practices free-range parenting.

@nbcnews

Mom Karyann Parkinson is speaking out tonight as a parenting debate grows online. Parkinson let her five-year-old son walk alone in their gated community in June. A security guard called police and Parkinson later faced six months of suspended jail time.

♬ original sound – nbcnews

Karyann was making lunch when 5-year-old Samuel walked to a pond in their community to collect goose feathers. It sounds like this was possibly a common occurrence for him or, at the very least, something that wouldn’t surprise Karyann. So when the security guard in the community spotted him and reported the incident, it may have been a surprise for the mom of five.

Karyann told USA Today, “I just love to give my kids those chances to have a little success under their belts, and you have to build that, you can’t expect kids to suddenly be able to walk down the street on their own if you don’t give them the chance.”

She also said that she believes kids are capable of doing more than many parents assume, and she takes opportunities that she sees to allow her kids to nurture their own independence. Yes, even at five years old.

Other parents have mixed reactions to the 5-year-old walking so far from home.

@menamakeshottakes Virginia Mom Gets 6-Month Suspended Jail Sentence for Letting 5-Year-Old Walk to the Pond. The government also placed Karyann Parkinson on its child abuse and neglect registry, where she will remain for seven years. In a gated community…Do parents know their children? #arresteddevelopment #parentsoftiktok #crimetok #overreacting #pov ♬ original sound – Mena Makes Hot Takes

In a Reddit thread about the incident, which saw Karyann receive six months of suspended jail time and seven years on the registry, some users questioned why Virginia’s “free range” parenting law did not apply to her. Others suggested that it was because she was slapped with a charge of contributing to the delinquency of a minor.

“Letting a 5-year-old go half a mile by themselves doesn’t sound like a good idea,” one Reddit user commented on the thread.

Another person responded, “Really? When I was five, It was routine for myself and the other neighborhood kids to walk seven blocks (that’s 7/10 of a mile) to school. I started first grade three months after my 5th birthday. The route took us by public housing, as well as being in an urban setting. I even did it alone at times.”

However, someone else added, “I think five is too young to be unsupervised around water. Especially a half mile from home. That’s crazy for a 5-year-old. Even one who has proved themselves capable before. Too much can happen too quickly around water like that.”

“I used to walk through the woods on my own as a kid to go play in a stream that was like a mile or two from my parents house, in a decidedly not gated community,” another user commented.

Freer range parenting is a growing movement.

Inside Edition/YouTube

In 2023, Virginia state passed a law protecting parents who use free-range parenting for their kids. The “Reasonable Childhood Independence” bill protects parents who let their children play outside, even in their front yard, but who would otherwise be targeted for neglect for not supervising them.

The bill does not protect parents who allow their children to be in danger, however. Whether or not that’s the case for Karyann and her conviction, her case was not protected under this law.

READ NEXT: Parenting Educator Condemns Jellyfish Parenting Trend, Saying It Makes Parents ‘Spineless’