If you know someone who, after a hard day of working or caring for kids, or you know, just existing, likes to kick back with a documentary about the most grisly murder ever committed, you might know a true crime lover.
True crime—the consuming of it, not participating in it, of course—is a popular pastime.
According to one report, a whopping 84% of the U.S. population absorbs some type of true crime, with podcasts leading the way.
Those who listen and engage with the content are apt to listen to all ranges, from serial killers to local murders to high-profile cases. And they’re not always mere bystanders either; many true crime enthusiasts also get involved, such as donating money to the victims or actively supporting a trial unfolding in real time.
One thing is for certain: true crime enthusiasts are their own niche, and if you know one, we have some great gift suggestions to show just how much you care.
Why Are People Fascinated With True Crime?
I have to be honest: I have often wondered this question myself, because I am the furthest from a true crime lover. I actively avoid all mention of it, and I can’t even watch scary movies.
But according to experts, true crime enthusiasts aren’t focused on thinking about the awful nature of the crimes or fixating on the victims, but instead are drawn more to the psychology behind the crime, as well as the allure of “solving” a mystery.
True crime can also offer an “escape” from real life, and the more outlandish the crime, the more fascinating the appeal. While you’re just going about your day, getting groceries, doing laundry, and going to work, someone else is out there, plotting murderers and texting their own daughter horrific messages while pretending to cooperate with the police?
It’s easy to see how you can get drawn into choices and scandals that seem so far from our ordinary lives.
For others, true crime can also be viewed as simply an entertaining hobby. My mom, for instance, loves true crime simply because she enjoys the “mystery” aspect of it and loves a good “whodunit.”
Regardless of the reason, if you stan for the true crime lover in your life, you can pick up one of these themed gifts that will make them gasp, chuckle, and maybe even dive deep into solving the mystery for themselves.
True Crime Detective Couch Division Shirt
This one made me LOL because it describes my mother perfectly. (No offense, Mom.) She absolutely loves watching all the gruesome and gory true crime shows and movies—safely from her perch on the couch, of course.
Choose multiple colors and sizes up through 3XL.
True Crime Fans, Mystery Advent Calendar: 12 Days of Deception Game
This is a really unique true crime gift idea that takes one gift and turns it into twelve days of mysterious fun. The gift is an Advent calendar, with each day revealing a new clue to help solve the mystery at Ravenwood Manor.
According to the description, the gift is “Clue meets a Netflix true crime series,” and it’s beautifully packaged and presented to boot, so it makes a great gift.
American Serial Killers Map
This one is downright frightening to me, but I suppose a person of a certain interest would enjoy it.
I also have to say, as someone who lives in a state with a very prominent red “dot” on this map, I was pretty freaked out, so maybe do some research before gifting it…
Crime Lover Mug
This is perfect for pouring out a cup of hot cocoa, tea, coffee, or a mystery brew while queuing up the latest episode of your loved one’s beloved true crime podcast. So refreshing and relaxing!
True Crime Candle
This just might be the ultimate compliment to a true true crime junkie…
Also, fwiw, this is a natural-poured soy candle with multiple scents available, so it’s a high-quality gift too!
Cereal Killer Bowl & Spoon Set
This one also made me chuckle, because it perfectly describes me at 10 PM in our house anytime we have Reese’s Puffs around…
Each bowl and spoon set is handmade and ships from Ohio. I am assuming these sets are not dishwasher safe, so proceed with caution, if you can stomach using them, of course.
True Crime Trivia Game
Test the true crime lover in your life’s trivia knowledge with this simple card game. It’s an affordable price and includes 140 true-crime-based trivia cards to challenge even the most die-hard of true crime enthusiasts.
Murder Most Puzzling: The Clairvoyants' Convention 500-Piece Puzzle
I love the concept of this gift, because it is two gifts in one. First, it’s a standalone puzzle, so any puzzle lover can enjoy putting it together. But in addition to being a puzzle, it’s also a mystery to solve. Opening the box reveals a mystery, including an audio narrative to listen to that sets the scene.
Then, the more pieces you put together, the more clues you reveal to solve the ultimate mystery. Once the puzzle is complete, the murderer will be revealed!
Bi-monthly True Crime Book Box
$43.99
from
Cozy Books Corner Box
Every other month, it’s the gift that keeps on giving, true crime style. You can buy one month, or if you’re feeling generous, gift a longer subscription.
Each box is curated for true crime lovers and includes a true crime book, along with edible treats, reading accessories, stickers, or other bookish goodies.
*Psst: if you choose to purchase an item from this post, CafeMom.com may receive a small cut. Each item and price is up to date at the time of publication; however, an item may be sold out or the price may be different at a later date.
