11 Creative Tooth Fairy Ideas to Celebrate That First (& Second …) Lost Tooth

In the old days, when a kid lost a tooth, they'd stick it under their pillow and find a quarter there the next morning. These days, the tooth fairy has gotten a lot more creative. And why not make it special? Losing a tooth is a huge physical milestone and cause for celebration.

If you're looking for ideas to commemorate your child's first lost tooth or want to start a new tooth fairy tradition (and trust us, you will when you see the ideas below), look no farther. We rounded up 11 creative ideas from our favorite bloggers that will help keep the tooth fairy magic alive.

tooth fairy diy ideas

We love #7 — which is your favorite?

How did you celebrate the arrival of the Tooth Fairy?

Images via Jose Luis Pelaez, Inc./Corbis; © iStock.com/bobbieo

Glitter Dollars

img-of-media-slide-119990.jpg
tenkidsandadog.blogspot.com

Joan, over at Ten Kids and a Dog, gave her son a fairy dust-coated dollar when he lost his first tooth. Want to know the secret? It's just glitter hair spray. Buy at any Halloween shop or party store.

Tooth Passport

img-of-media-slide-119992.jpg
shapedbygracelife.blogspot.com

Maybe your child travels between two homes, or maybe you just like to have an official keepsake location for all of their tooth fairy visits. Reannah, blogging for Homemaker in Heels, created this nifty little Tooth Fairy passport, where kids can keep a tally of all of their teeth, along with a little pouch for their lost ones.

Tooth Travels Punch Card

img-of-media-slide-119993.jpg
shapedbygracelife.blogspot.com

But that's not all! Make and keep a tooth passport punch card that you can mark every time your kiddo loses another tooth.

Tooth Taxis

img-of-media-slide-119994.jpg
eastcoastmommyblog.blogspot.ca

Alternatively, if you want the tooth to travel between places, you can fasten yourself a little tooth taxi. Gina, a.k.a. East Coast Mommy, has the DIY idea for you, along with the easy printable labels.

Give a Lesson

img-of-media-slide-119996.png
meaningfulmama.com

Use it as a chance to teach the kids a little lesson. Is their bedroom a little dirty? Can the Tooth Fairy not get anywhere? This hilarious letter from the tooth fairy, courtesy of Meaningful Mama, will teach your kids some much-needed tidying tricks.

Invoice

img-of-media-slide-119998.jpg
howdoesshe.com

If you'd like to give your kids a little more freedom in requesting Tooth Fairy treats (within reason, of course!), check out this free printable tooth fairy invoice and step-by-step instructions from How Does She.

Glitter Steps

img-of-media-slide-120004.jpg
Sarah Quinn

This one's as easy as it gets. Some glitter, and one common toy, will create this amazing Tooth Fairy footprint trick.

Color-Changing Potion

img-of-media-slide-119999.jpg
howdoesshe.com

Before your child goes to bed, leave the tooth in a glass of water near her bed. During the night, the Tooth Fairy snatches the tooth and colors the water the color of her dress that night, so it'll change with each lost tooth.

Get Photo Proof

img-of-media-slide-120000.jpg
iCaughtTheToothFairy.com

If you would like your child to have some photographic evidence of the Tooth Fairy's visit, try out iCaughtTheToothFairy.com. Take a picture of your child, upload to the site, paste a Tooth Fairy onto the photo, and print. Leave it under the child's pillow or next to their bed, and watch them revel when they see their pic alongside the Tooth Fairy.

Tooth Fairy Doors

img-of-media-slide-120002.jpg
jaimeerose.com

How else would a Tooth Fairy enter the room? Place a special Tooth Fairy door on a bookshelf or tack it to the wall, right above the baseboard, and use it solely as the Fairy's entrance.

Tooth Fairy Pillow

img-of-media-slide-120019.jpg
houseforfive.com

Here's another handy idea for storing a tooth for the Tooth Fairy: House of Five suggests making this easy sew tooth pillow, then attaching to your child's bed post. The little stitched-on tooth has an opening where you can easily slide that little lost one in and wait for the Fairy to arrive.