How to Make Poached Eggs, Perfectly

Poached eggs are absolutely delicious — unless you don't like eggs, in which case stop reading now (there are many egg photos ahead). But I have a confession to make: Despite the fact that I like to call myself a pretty solid cook, I couldn't poach an egg. Oh, the shame!

It was a culinary skill that completely and totally eluded me. A batch would come out too vinegary while another turned into a cloudy mess in the pan, and the one after, just the yolks emerged from the simmering water completely cooked.

So in the name of all that is good and glorious about food, I decided to once and for all conquer my fear of egg poaching. I turned to two solid sources for instruction: Julia Child's Mastering the Art of French Cooking and Alton Brown's Perfect Poached Egg recipe and video.* Both were massively helpful.

This is what I found out, and good luck to you, brave fellow egg lover. The task that lies before might seem hard, but just start a gentle chant of "Eggs Benedict" to keep you going.

* If you do refer to Alton Brown's link above, know that the video and the recipe below vary slightly!

how to poach an egg

Images via Caylin Harris

Ingredients & Tools

img-of-media-slide-155098.jpg
Caylin Harris

You're going to need:

  • eggs (the fresher, the better)
  • water
  • vinegar
  • a non-stick skillet
  • a clean ruler
  • small ramekins
  • a slotted spoon
  • a cooking thermometer
  • a plate
  • a clean towel

Step 1

img-of-media-slide-154849.jpg
Caylin Harris

Pulling from the two sources I mentioned, here is what worked for me. 

Pour water into your nonstick skillet until there is 1.5 inches of water. I measured just to be precise with my clean ruler. Julia Child recommends two inches, but I had the most success with using 1.5. Start heating the water on medium-low heat until you've got it gently simmering.

Step 2

img-of-media-slide-154850.jpg
Caylin Harris

Crack your desired number of eggs into separate, small ramekins. One egg in each and set them aside.

Step 3

img-of-media-slide-154851.jpg
Caylin Harris

Add a tablespoon of vinegar to the water. Julia recommends adding a tablespoon per quart, but I went with Alton Brown's suggestion of one. I think in previous attempts I had added a little too much, hence an overpowering vinegar taste.

More from The Stir: How Couples Decide Who Really Belongs in the Kitchen (PHOTOS)

Step 4

img-of-media-slide-154852.jpg
Caylin Harris

Now here was the life-changing info that Alton Brown brought to this whole process: Using a cooking thermometer, check to see that the water has reached 190 degrees (F) before gently (and placing the ramekin into the water) tilting the egg into the water.

Step 5

img-of-media-slide-154853.jpg
Caylin Harris

Set a timer for 4.5 minutes and just let the eggs cook. Don't touch them or anything; I know other recipes may recommend trying to push the white of the egg over the yolk, but I found that I didn't need to mess with it.

Step 6

img-of-media-slide-154854.jpg
Caylin Harris

Using the slotted spoon, gently remove the two poached eggs from the water and place them on a clean towel on a plate. I've tried rinsing them off before, and it just made them cold, so as long as you're eating right away and have used the amount of vinegar mentioned above, you should be fine to serve them up any way you like!

Yum!

img-of-media-slide-155097.jpg
Caylin Harris

And voilà! Bon appétit!

Thank you, Julia Child and Alton Brown, for the culinary guidance. 

More from The Stir: 6 Crock-Pot Breakfast Recipes That Will Make You Want to Rise & Dine