Madeline Soto’s Mother ‘Oblivious’ to Boyfriend’s Alleged Abuse of Daughter Before Murder

On February 26, 2024, 13-year-old Madeline Soto went missing from her home in Kissimmee, Florida. Several days later, on March 1, the teenager’s body was found in a wooded area, the Orange County Sheriff’s Office said at the time. Prior to her body being found, police arrested her mother’s boyfriend, Stephan Sterns, and charged him with possessing child sexual abuse material. The CSAM was unrelated to both Madeline’s death and her disappearance.

On April 24, Sterns was charged with Madeline’s murder. Since the charge, more details about Sterns’ alleged abuse of Madeline have emerged, and police are questioning how much Madeline’s mother knew before her daughter’s death.

More from CafeMom: Woman Details Being Impregnated by Her Stepdad at Age 12 in New Kamala Harris Campaign Ad

Her mother made a shocking revelation.

Click 2 Orlando reported that Jennifer Soto, Madeline Soto’s mother, told police that the night before Madeline’s disappearance, she had asked her then-boyfriend Stephan Sterns and Madeline to sleep in the bedroom upstairs so she could get a “good night’s sleep.” She had already claimed that the three had shared a bed regularly.

During the nearly three-hour interrogation, police pushed Jennifer Soto, saying that they believed she knew about Sterns sexually abusing her daughter.

More from CafeMom: Dad Allegedly Shoots His Daughter’s Stepfather After She Accuses Him of Sexual Assault

Jennifer Soto maintained that she knew nothing about the alleged abuse.

“I believe that you became aware of their sexual relationship,” the detectives told her. “I think at a certain point throughout this relationship, you became aware of it, and for whatever reason — your reasons are your reasons, whether it was discussed that it would stop, whether it was discussed how it would go — that you feel some sense of guilt.”

But Jennifer Soto insisted that she had “no idea.” She claimed Sterns “never mentioned anything. I’ve never seen any signs.” She also said “I tried watching her like a hawk. I thought I was doing a good job, but I wasn’t. I was oblivious to everything.”

Police did not think Jennifer Soto was emotional enough about her daughter's death.

Despite Jennifer Soto crying throughout the interview with police, an incident report released by the Orange County Sheriff’s Office and shared by Click 2 Orlando called her emotions “fictitious.”

“During portions of the interview, [she] continuously protected Stephan Sterns, was questioned about why she prioritizes Stephan Sterns over [REDACTED] and even at one point referred to the ‘sex stuff’ as not evil but the murder of [REDACTED] as ‘evil.’ The interview eventually ended, but [Soto’s mother] did not show the same level of emotion or care in regards to [REDACTED] ongoing victimization by Stephan Sterns than she did her disappearance. It appeared to me that she has already accepted that the victimization was happening,” the report reads.

Sterns had allegedly long been abusing Madeline.

Mugshot of Stephan Sterns
Orange County Jail

When Madeline’s body was discovered, deputies said they had evidence showing Sterns had been abusing the girl for years and regularly slept with her. In August, the sheriff’s office released a case supplemental report. The report claimed that when she learned that police found photos and videos showing Sterns allegedly sexually abusing a child, Jennifer Soto said, “He’s been grooming and abusing my child,” according to reports from  FOX 35WFTV, and Click 2 Orlando.

Ultimately, Sterns was charged with first-degree murder in April, in connection with Madeline’s death. He has also pleaded not guilty to 60 counts of sexual abuse charges, the Osceola News-Gazette reported. Jennifer Soto has not been charged in connection with the case.

If you suspect child abuse, you can call the Childhelp National Child Abuse Hotline at 1-800-422-4453 (1-800-4-A-Child), or go to Childhelp.org. The hotline is available 24/7.