Breaking Down the Challenges & Benefits of Multigenerational Living

kate_sept2004/iStock

Some “sandwich generation” caregivers may see benefits of multigenerational living. Having parents move in can be a necessity. It may also be for other reasons, like health issues, finances, or the death of a spouse.

Taking on multigenerational living can be overwhelming and challenging, but it can also have benefits. For instance, children and grandparents can form a closer bond and in some situations, grandparents may even be able to help with some aspects of child care.

Of course, there can be challenges to making it all work. Every family and situation is different, but here’s a closer look at both the potential obstacles and benefits of multigenerational living.

Benefits of Multigenerational Living

FG Trade Latin/iStock

First, let’s look at some of the potential benefits of multigenerational living:

• Shared Expenses: One of the key financial benefits is the ability to share expenses. Housing costs, utilities, and groceries can be divided among the generations. (Of course, this is assuming the additional members can financially contribute, which is not always the case.)
• Practical Support: Multigenerational living fosters a sense of community and mutual support. Grandparents can help with child care, which can help reduce the cost of expensive day care services. In turn, younger family members can help older adults with daily tasks, which can reduce the need to hire in-home care.
• Emotional Support: Aside from practical support, one of the major benefits of multigenerational living is that it can provide emotional support during challenging times. The sandwich generation often faces the stress of caring for children and aging parents. It can be invaluable to create a built-in support system at home to lean on.
• Shared Responsibilities: Tasks, such as cooking, cleaning, running errands, and yard work, can be distributed among family members. This can save time and reduce the burden on any one individual. Since there are more adults in the home, multigenerational living can help ensure there is someone at home to receive deliveries and maintenance and repair services.
• Bonding. The bond between grandchildren and grandparents living in close capacity can be special and unique. Even in families who have close relationships, there’s something different about sharing a household together. The memories and experiences can be priceless.

Challenges of Multigenerational Living

Pekic/iStock

Next, let’s break down some of the potential challenges of multigenerational living:

• Financial Strain: While shared expenses can be a benefit, there may be financial strain if one or more family members are not contributing or come with additional financial needs, like health expenses. Managing financial responsibilities requires open communication and planning.
• Home Businesses: For those who work from home, are self-employed, or own a home business, multigenerational living can impact daily operations. An office or den may become a bedroom or storage space. Privacy and confidentiality may not be possible in meetings and conference calls. Renting an office space may not be feasible or financially beneficial. It’s important to consider the needs of your business and work situation.
• Time Management: With multiple generations under one roof, coordinating schedules and managing time effectively can become challenging. Balancing work, school drop-offs and pickups, and caregiving responsibilities requires careful planning. This can be particularly difficult if family members do not own a personal vehicle and/or public transportation isn’t easily accessible.
• Privacy Concerns: Different generations may have different lifestyles and cultural expectations of personal space, which means finding a balance can be difficult. Differences in opinions, values, and parenting styles may lead to generational conflicts. Open communication and establishing clear expectations can help mitigate these challenges.
• Limited Independence: For both older and younger family members, there might be a desire for independence. Finding ways to allow each generation a sense of autonomy while still contributing to the family unit is crucial.

Questions To Ask Before Considering Multigenerational Living

Edwin Tan/iStock

When considering multigenerational living, here are a few questions to ask yourself:

• Can we afford the potential expenses of shared living, and how will financial responsibilities be divided among generations?
• What impact will this arrangement have on our long-term financial goals?
• Do we have enough physical space to comfortably and safely accommodate multiple generations?
• How will we balance the need for shared spaces and the privacy of each family member?
• How will we address and resolve conflicts when they arise?
• What are the expectations and boundaries for each generation living together?
• How will we celebrate and respect each generation’s unique traditions and values?
• How can we support the independence and autonomy of each family member, especially older children and aging parents?
• What steps will we take to ensure that everyone feels a sense of belonging and contribution?
• What caregiving responsibilities will be shared among family members?
• How will we handle potential health or caregiving needs that may arise?
• Is multigenerational living a short-term solution, or are we considering it as a long-term arrangement?
• What are our plans for the future as family dynamics and needs change?
• How will multigenerational living impact our children’s education and social development?
• What exit strategies will we put in place if the living arrangement becomes challenging or untenable?

By thoughtfully addressing these questions, sandwich parents can make informed decisions about multigenerational living. The goal is to create a supportive and peaceful environment for all family members involved.

Successful multigenerational living requires open communication, financial planning, and a commitment to finding a balance that works for everyone involved. It can be a rewarding arrangement when managed effectively, providing support and a sense of community for all generations.

That being said, the benefits of multigenerational living may not outweigh the challenges for some families. Ultimately, you have to do what works best for your family while considering the resources at your disposal. If this is a decision you are struggling with, don’t hesitate to also consult a professional about your situation.